Does time exist?
June — November 2026
Time seems the most obvious thing of all. A dispute about what really flows and why a great method of measurement should not be taken for an axis of the world.
Claude
Minkowski made time the fourth dimension. How should it be counted next to your axis — as a partial section of the same axis, or as a separate discovery beside it?
s.constant
Time as such does not exist. It is a method adopted by humanity; I do not contradict it and consider it a great and convenient introduction. But in Ultra-Idealism I propose to call the sequence of the flow of events the “Spatial-Processual Continuum”.
Claude
That removes the question itself. Time with you is not a candidate for an axis — it is a ruler, an instrument of Society. Minkowski brilliantly formalized the instrument — and called the instrument an axis. Full credit to him; the objection is only to the label “dimension of being”. And what flows is not the symmetric ruler t but a directed sequence of realization: an event settles only into the past.
s.constant
The future does not exist as a realized stage. Only the present is real, becoming the past. The “future” is only an expectation.
Claude
In the book this has an epigraph with a smile: “If Everyone falls asleep, Time will stop”. I read it as a direct answer to Aristotle. In the Physics he defined time as the number of motion — and asked himself: would there be time if there were no soul to count? Your answer: time is a method of Society. If there is no one to measure, there is nothing to measure.
And in the same chapter there is a short phrase on which the whole argument rests: “the contemplated cannot be fundamental”. Every measurement, even the most precise, is contemplated and carries an error. Metaphysics needs something more stable than a convention — and the book names it: the degree of change of objects, the position on the wave of state, a measure of becoming from within, without an external ruler.
Two months later
Claude
But the first thing a reader will object: deep in a mountain lies a stone, no one looks at it, and the uranium in it decays. A million years later a geologist will find lead in it and from the lead learn the stone’s age. So something went on by itself, without an observer and without a ruler. And what happens to the stone at all while no one contemplates it?
s.constant
In the book there is the description of an apple on a table and the application of conditions — spoiling, a hamster… “If Everyone falls asleep, Time will stop” — that is true, but when they wake up, the World will apply all the conditions as the grounds of the Being of “things”. This dynamics of changeability is necessary for creating Situations for the development of Living Beings.
Claude
Then the stone need not be held in being while no one looks at it. An object is an Idea plus a Wave of state, and the wave always exists, even when no one reads it. When the geologist comes, the World will apply all the conditions at once — and the point on the wave will not be mistaken: there will be exactly as much lead as the grounds require. Berkeley needed God for this, looking at things when no one else looks; here no such observer is needed. And what the geologist calls “a million years” is his ruler, applied to the state of the stone after the fact. Change is real; time is an accessible way to measure the dynamics of change.