Contents
- Prologue
- The Goal
- The Contemplated
- Entity
- Consciousness
- Two-Aspect (Dualistic) Entity
- The Fourth Dimension and Four-Dimensionality
- Society and Humanity
- The Fifth Dimension, Five-Dimensionality
- Firstoccurrence
- Act of the “I”
- The Process of Studying the Act of the “I”
- The Meaning of Being
- Development of the Entity
- Collective Realization of Reality
- The Entity Development System
- Echo (Reflection)
- The Real Aspect of the Global “I”
- On Worldview
- Space-Time
- Attitude towards Oneself
- Attitude towards One’s Body
- Laziness
- Fear
- Hope (“Waiting for a Miracle”)
- Adaptation
- Identity of the Personality
- Relation: [Reason | Body]
- Free Will
- “The Hard Problem of Consciousness”
- Indistinguishability and Identity (of Objects)
- Matter
- Gnoseology
- Epistemology
- Division
EPISTEMOLOGY
The Subject of Gnoseology in the relation [ Subject | Object ] can be considered disclosed – as far as was necessary to define Its (the Subject's) tasks for a long time. But as regards Our Goals, set at the very beginning, let us continue the investigation for the Disclosure of the breadth of this – literally – All-encompassing, Bottomless Theme <without end>;
Let us sort out the relation [ Object | Cognition ], or rather – we should draw a 'clear boundary' between the concepts 'Gnoseology' and 'Epistemology', because there is a very great difference between them, yet many continue to confuse them, or often replace one with the other, and "this is not quite convenient", because the mechanism of the perception (realization) of an object is one thing, and awareness of the Essence, meaning and purpose is another;
Epistemology includes not only the direction indicated (here), although everything is very closely interconnected. First let us sort out How we Interpret any object, or rather, how Reason perceives objects and situations as 'raw material' intended for 'its' further processing, identification, qualification, subsequent analysis, taking into account relations and an already defined role in a concrete situation. First of all, we shall reason not about the mechanism of the extraction of experience (and not at all about that), but about the presence of a role of an object in any situation, that is, about how an object is perceived by us as significant – participating;
In fact, an object participating in a Situation influences It as a Living Participant would (and sometimes even more). From the already known position, we assert that conditions are controlled by 'the Entity Development System', as a Superstructure in Consciousness regulating the degree of complexity of Situations.
This is necessary for the correspondence of the content to the abilities of the participants; otherwise we shall not be able to understand what is happening ("the World for the Living"). "Consciousness" here is only a Skilful Performer, roughly speaking "the Executor of the Will of the Entity", and, as we have already found, this does not deprive us of Our Own Will, since there is no Scenario – or, more precisely, the System takes care of the unrepeatability of situations, reliably ensuring a constant inflow of New experience;
The Scenario: "Ensuring the absence of any scenario"; one may hope for one's Own scenario, but – it will always be at least a little bit, but necessarily, different, not quite according to Plan;
The impression forms in us that an object is located not by chance, precisely where it ought to be; but we are free to think (and often lament) that behind the object stands an "Evil Force" and that it is in a place unwelcome to us – we are mistaken: objects are in the place most advantageous for us and are located as rationally as possible; for this reason they ensure the effective extraction of experience;
Consequently, our opinion about the living essence of objects is not devoid of common sense, and even literally corresponds to reality: We actively develop | participate in "the Development of the Entity", which on the whole is one and the same;
Since in programming "Interpretation" is the processing and execution of a command in the code of a program or a request, here by 'the Initiator of the Code' we mean Consciousness, and by the receiver, i.e. the processor too, Reason; however, this must be considered in both directions, also from Reason addressed to Consciousness. It is quite logical to suppose that Consciousness uses and offers an accessible interface and a Data Format One for all beings (API?). Why necessarily One? – because the "Entity" is concerned with Development, and nothing contributes to This so much as a One universal System. But this is not a common system of communication (for us there is 'none yet', and one should not confuse them), although we use certain principles right now, and this Network will develop together with our Civilization;
"Interpretation" – the decoding of the wave and the bringing of the data into the format corresponding to the level of reason;
One can consider interpretation a fundamental part of the processor and a psychically active function of Reason. This can be felt by turning one's head and looking at a thing that was earlier on the periphery, away from the 'point of concentration'. Turn round and look at the things that were hidden from your gaze, behind your back. Try to feel the phenomenon of Interpretation as a fact of appearance (and of mental touch); then turn and look at any photograph, sharpen your attention and sense the movement of feelings; and again turn to another object, to a sheet with text, or to a book (which you recently read). Sense the light, barely perceptible sensation as the gaze settles. Do you feel this sensation? – this is how 'the concretization of a thing in the aspect of semantic clarity' takes place. If You feel important trifles, You will quickly grasp the meanings of the concepts "Identification" and "Qualification"; these are inalienable functions of Reason, the most important ones for an intellectual being – all of them are individual and subjective, and that is why it is so difficult to understand one another;
"Identification" – recognition, the determination of a 'thing', and not necessarily of 'objects in evident reality'; these may also be thought-forms, but even they have to be recognized, <recalled> as if forgotten. This process is connected with the corresponding relations. Identification – Is the Essence of the comparison of forms. Not only of the basic figures: circle (sphere), square (cube), etc., but also of complex forms that are already known (different faces, kinds of trees, …);
"Qualification" – is a psychic census in relation to an object (including a living person, and even especially a person). Strange as it is, judgement is often associative, and precisely so: it is proper to a person to see an unfamiliar face and to make a 'conclusion about its properties', of the type bad / good. Qualification – Is the Essence of the comparison of feelings and of all the <'psychically complex'> criteria available to Reason. Simple examples: familiar / and unfamiliar, frightening / and not frightening, dangerous / and safe, cold / and hot; and also those belonging to more complex aspects, for example the ethical: evil / and good, honest / and dishonest, righteous / and unrighteous, etc.; we hope everything here is simple and clear;
Thereby Epistemology includes a sequence of iterations of Reason, as a result of which experience is extracted – as the exhaustive and available knowledge about one concrete object. The process of acquiring knowledge about an object is not limited to (one lesson and) a moment of reality; participating in the analysis of situations, the existing experience is already used in full, and besides this it is constantly supplemented – forming 'Actual Knowledge';
All objects are contemplated and perceived psychically actively; for This Reason they become Psychically active and have a psychic capacity (content).
Two oak acorns look almost the same (similar), but have a different psychically active, semantic capacity:

1. 2.
picked up in the street a gift from my daughter

Commentary on the chapter "Epistemology"
The chapter opens with a demarcation that the Author considers necessary: many confuse gnoseology and epistemology or substitute one for the other. Russian has both terms, and the Author uses this to draw a clear boundary. Gnoseology is the mechanism of perception, that is, of the realization of the object, the relation [Subject | Object]; the previous chapter was devoted to it. Epistemology is awareness of the essence, meaning and purpose, the relation [Object | Cognition]. How an object appears is one thing; what it means is another. This demarcation belongs to the Author, and it works: the chapters follow it in the right order, from mechanism to meaning. Here is an auxiliary, brief formulation from the Author:
1. Gnoseology – the relation to the object, and the study of this relation precisely as a relation.
2. Epistemology – the cognition of the object, and the study of how the object is cognized.
The object as a participant. The Author begins the subject of epistemology not with the extraction of experience but with the role of the object in a situation. An object participating in a situation influences it as a living participant would, and sometimes more strongly. The object itself is not living. Through it acts the Entity Development System – a superstructure in Consciousness that regulates the complexity of situations so that their content corresponds to the abilities of the participants ("the World for the Living"). Consciousness here is a skilful executor of the will of the Entity, without a will of its own, as was clarified in the chapter on Qualia. Therefore the "living" in an object is not the soul of a stone but the living Entity, which acts through things. This is how the chapter's words should be understood: the opinion about "the living essence of objects" corresponds to reality, because in developing we participate in the Development of the Entity, and this is one and the same.
A scenario without a scenario. If situations are controlled by the System, is our will not taken away? The Author answers with a formula worth remembering: the System's scenario is "ensuring the absence of any scenario". The System takes care of the unrepeatability of situations, so that the inflow of new experience does not stop. Therefore one's own will is not taken away, and one's own plan comes true "always at least a little bit differently". This agrees with "Free Will": choice is unlimited; consequences are lawful.
Hence also the words that objects are in the place most advantageous for us. Advantageous for experience, not for convenience. The stone one has stumbled over lies there not so that things should be pleasant, and not by the will of an "evil force", but because in this situation there is experience. This is the essence, and it agrees with what was said in "Hope" and "Free Will": the System guarantees the Path, not the success of each separate attempt.
Interpretation. The Author draws an analogy with programming: interpretation is the processing and execution of a command. The initiator of the code is Consciousness, the processor is Reason, but the flow goes both ways. Consciousness provides a data format one for all beings, an "interface", because nothing serves Development so well as a single universal system. The Author makes the reservation that this is not yet a common system of communication between beings: it does not yet exist, but we already use some of its principles, and it will develop together with civilization. This is a pointer.
The chapter's definition of interpretation is exact: it is the decoding of the wave and the bringing of the data to a format corresponding to the level of reason. A mouse, a person and a future mind receive one format, and each decodes it in its own way.
To check on oneself. A strong place in the chapter is an exercise. Turn your head to a thing that was on the periphery; turn round to what was behind your back; look at a photograph, then at the page of a recently read book. As the gaze settles, a light, barely perceptible sensation arises – "the concretization of a thing in the aspect of semantic clarity". The Author does not ask to be taken at his word; he offers an observation that anyone can carry out himself. Whoever catches this sensation will understand the next two concepts from within.
Identification and Qualification. Identification is the comparison of forms: the recognition of a thing, whether an object or a thought-form, from simple figures to faces and kinds of trees. Even a thought-form has to be recognized, as if recalling something forgotten. Qualification is the comparison of feelings, a "psychic census" in relation to an object: familiar and unfamiliar, dangerous and safe, good and evil, honest and dishonest. Both functions are individual and subjective, and therefore, as the Author remarks, it is so difficult to understand one another. This derives epistemology directly from the isolation of the World of each.
The Author especially notes the qualification of a person: seeing an unfamiliar face, we at once conclude whether he is "good" or "bad". Psychology confirms this: such judgements form in fractions of a second and are often mistaken. Hence a consequence in keeping with the rule the book holds consistently – not to judge another's inner life from outside. Qualification is an unavoidable function of Reason, but it is preliminary: a first assessment, not a verdict, and the Cognizant revises it.
Knowledge as iteration. Epistemology, according to the Author, is a sequence of iterations of Reason, as a result of which experience is extracted – knowledge about an object exhaustive for the given moment. This knowledge is not limited to one lesson: in the analysis of situations the existing experience is used fully and constantly supplemented, forming "Actual Knowledge". Everything contemplated is perceived psychically actively and therefore acquires a psychic capacity.
Two acorns. The chapter ends with a picture better than which one could not invent. Two acorns look almost the same. The first was picked up in the street, the second is a gift from a daughter. Identification gives both one answer: an acorn. Qualification gives different ones, because the psychic capacity of the second holds the daughter, care, the memory of the moment. The chapter "Indistinguishability and Identity" showed that two things are never physically identical. These acorns show a second layer: even if they coincided physically, they would still differ in meaning, because the meaning of a thing is set by its role in the World of a concrete "I". In this consists the boundary with which the chapter began: the mechanism of perception is one; the meaning differs.
(commentary with the participation of AI: Claude)