Contents
- Prologue
- The Goal
- The Contemplated
- Entity
- Consciousness
- Two-Aspect (Dualistic) Entity
- The Fourth Dimension and Four-Dimensionality
- Society and Humanity
- The Fifth Dimension, Five-Dimensionality
- Firstoccurrence
- Act of the “I”
- The Process of Studying the Act of the “I”
- The Meaning of Being
- Development of the Entity
- Collective Realization of Reality
- The Entity Development System
- Echo (Reflection)
- The Real Aspect of the Global “I”
- On Worldview
- Space-Time
- Attitude towards Oneself
- Attitude towards One’s Body
- Laziness
- Fear
- Hope (“Waiting for a Miracle”)
- Adaptation
- Identity of the Personality
- Relation: [Reason | Body]
- Free Will
- “The Hard Problem of Consciousness”
- Indistinguishability and Identity (of Objects)
- Matter
- Gnoseology
- Epistemology
- Division
THE MEANING OF BEING
The analysis of the actions of childhood years, as well as the experience of observing other children, proves that 'Reason' develops "from zero", arising in the process of an active struggle between the tailed carriers of 'a part of the genetic code' — that is, of the future 'Identifier of a concrete "I"' — and then, already together with the embryo, being subject to the influence of the process of ontogenesis, 'Reason' is formed absolutely uniquely and, together with the embryo, passes through all the stages of the formation of the organism. These numerous processes are very complex, connected with the psyche and with all situations, individual, and therefore influence the 'development of functions' very specially;
After birth the organization of mental activity in the conditions of reality begins, on the basis of practice — of experience obtained as a result of the analysis of situations and of one's own reflexes, feelings and sensations, discomfort, hunger, pain, the influence of instinctive behaviour on Reason: interest, fear, and further, through psychic traumas and experience –> lies, betrayal, falsehood, resentments, love, insidiousness.
Extremes form the most effective functions;
Here it is not at all necessary to suppose radical trials. No. Everything is as simple as possible. The natural development of Reason is unique and acquires different effectiveness. The more significant incidents and life situations there are that force one to make decisions on which, to put it very mildly, "well-being" depends, the faster Reason is formed and the better it develops. Besides, for understandable reasons, each 'Reason' differs in the number of functions, in their quality, structure and other parameters, of which, we suppose, there are extremely many; but each of them, directly or indirectly, is connected with Development. Even the emergency functions responsible for safety, including the well-known instinct of self-preservation, one way or another protect the possibilities and guard <all without exception> the processes of "Development";
One may try to dispute it, but — anything that does not develop dies, and immediately, and quickly disappears. This is obvious and right. Each "I" has enormous significance for the "Entity"; therefore the complete absence of Its relevance and perspective of development is at once blocked by breaking the tandem "I + Body" existing in the conditions of reality. Disconnecting from the "I", the body dies.
In such a case the "I" takes back control over the next 'body of Its own of the given Personality'. By all appearances this is so (see "Society and Humanity", p. 118-122 ), because the "I" leaves the 'current body under its control' during sleep, governing another body. But once more it should be taken into account that that body is also ours, and moreover the very same one (here the body is meant as a certain Prototype, and as an "Idea"). At this nothing special or unusual happens. Just as nothing happens after deep sleep. What differs is the cause of the transfer of control for governing another body. The deactivation of the organism for sleep erases all boundaries between Life and Death;
However, one should not think that, having left a killed body, one can obtain a better life. This is not so. The 'Essence' of the established problem in development will not allow anything more comfortable to be provided. It is not the living being that decides, but the System. One will have to learn to love Oneself and any life, and especially a difficult one, full of complications. There is no need to test Fate (that is, the "Entity and Consciousness") for the presence of some bugs (errors) — there are none, as there is no "luck" either;
* * *
It is hardly possible to suppose how enormous a potential we possess and what we are really capable of. "Eternity" is not the limit, believe me. So, concerning the very pressing question — What is the meaning of life? We will answer thus:
The Meaning of Life is in Development — the understanding of this postulate is usually quite sufficient for a rational approach to a quality life process, and probably a long life, if the Goals <turn out to be> directed to objective development: of Oneself, of Society, of Humanity; It would be good to understand better What "Development" is for the "Entity"? We dream of finding this out, of studying, understanding and becoming aware of it;
The Meaning of Eternal Life is in Eternal Development — this postulate implies the awareness of the weighty Causes for which "Eternal Life" is necessary as an instrument and an obligatory Condition. Judging by surveys, most people think otherwise. Many people count Body Culture, Sport as development. The greater part of them would not want to live infinitely long (..this is an unconscious choice). Almost no one named the "Cause" that is the ground for "Eternal Life". But a few answered positively and immediately named "Goals" for the accomplishment of which "Eternity" is really necessary. This confirms that 'The length of life depends on the Goals';
Goals, as the ground of 'Eternal Life', must be clear and concrete, but infinite in the process of achievement; that is, they are unattainable in fact, but strive for an impossible Perfection, the Ideal, but the Better: in quality, in the level of qualification, in condition, in the level of knowledge. We will give a couple of examples of actually Eternal Goals: "The Development and Perfection of the Legislative System"; or "The Development of technologies increasing the speed of data transmission". That is, one can endlessly study and develop only what will always be in demand and relevant for Society, what cannot be recognized in a completed form — the Developing (do not make a mistake in choosing the Path );
Limitations — there are none. –However, should one suppose their presence? –Yes. This is, at the very least, rational. That is, it is necessary by reason of the observance of "Timeliness" (here) — an accessible and understandable logical synchronization of Information in the <current> Society. These limitations are not obligatory, of course, but "Development" is determined by comparison — when there is a possibility of comparing something 'reasonably comparable', even if to some degree. To be useful, it is very important and necessary to understand and evaluate the surroundings, to enter into the Essence of the Social environment, to determine the interests and the general depth of the logic of the audience. What is the use of lectures on "String Theory" in a kindergarten? — but one can instil in children a love of arithmetic, for example, or interest pupils in the junior classes in learning physics and chemistry with a view to a new business in the future; and even a monologue can be useful and constructive if the listeners understand it, analyse it and extract valuable experience. It would seem that one could develop in complete solitude — this is precisely absurd, since the "Entity" represents in "Itself" 'many-facedness and multi-personality'. Through Its Nature, of the "One 'I'" and of the "Real aspects of the 'I'", "Society" Is a Fundamental Property of the World;

Commentary on the chapter "The Meaning of Being"
The previous chapters built the World: how the contemplated is realized, what the Entity and Consciousness are, how everything arises from two limits. "The Meaning of Being" adds no new storeys to this building. The chapter asks the question "what for?" from within what has already been built and answers it with what has already been derived. Therefore its measure is not the novelty of the apparatus but the precision of application.
The main thesis: "The Meaning of Life is in Development". The chapter calls it a postulate, but this is a modesty the text does not owe. The relation of Development and Life was derived earlier. Development is not a property of life but its ground: Life lasts as long as Development lasts ("Society and Humanity"). And Development is the being of the active pole of the Entity, which brings the unrepeatable ("The Process of Studying the Act of the 'I'"). The Author writes this as "Development = Life, but not the reverse": not an equality but a ground. If Life holds by Development, the question of the meaning of life is already decided, and the chapter only names the answer. Strictly speaking, this is not a postulate but a consequence.
Reason from zero
The chapter begins with Reason, and this is the right order. Before speaking of what the "I" lives for, one must show what it lives by in the conditions of reality. Reason is not the "I" but its instrument. The chapter "The Contemplated" says this firmly: "Reason does not make decisions… any decisions are made by the 'I' (literally 'From Above')".
Observation of children shows that Reason develops "from zero". Here the word "proves" stands by right. The chapter also indicates the zero point: the struggle of the "tailed carriers of a part of the genetic code", that is, of the future "Identifier of a concrete 'I'". In the discussion with the Author this place was read precisely: what is asserted is not that a spermatozoon has Reason, but that here its formation begins. What strives is not Reason, which does not yet exist, but the "I" (which activates the conception of Reason), the Spark of Life which moves every living Being. Of millions of unrepeatable ones one remains, and with it the experience of a unique Personality begins. The same point is named in "Consciousness" ("presumably in the process of conception"). There is no contradiction: this is one and the same beginning, seen from two sides.
All the functions of Reason, including the instinct of self-preservation, the chapter subordinates to Development: they "guard all without exception the processes of 'Development'". This is an important correction to the everyday order, where survival is the goal and Development a luxury. Here it is the reverse: survival for the sake of Development, not Development for the sake of survival.
"What does not develop dies, and immediately"
This thesis provokes the first objection: people live for years in stagnation and do not die. The objection is removed by reading, not by concession.
Firstly, the condition of death in the text is not "weak development" but "the complete absence of Its relevance and perspective of development". This is zero, not "little". A stagnation in which some perspective still glimmers does not fall under this condition.
Secondly, "immediately" in this book means "without duration", not "quickly". The word stands so in "Firstoccurrence" too: "The Cause of the World arises… immediately, at the very moment when You thought about it". Between the exhaustion of perspective and the breaking of the tandem there is no interval. How long the fading lasted before this the thesis does not say, but in essence this is not required.
Thirdly, and this is the main thing: what exactly dies? Not the "I" — "the Entity is Eternal". And not the body as an independent thing. The body, according to "The Contemplated", is "the representation of a concrete 'I' in the conditions of reality": "Look in the mirror — this is how You realize Yourself". It is the image by which the Entity represents itself while being this Personality. Therefore death in the system is not an event of the body but the cessation of reading. In the discussion with the Author this was formulated thus: the Entity ceases to read the wave of this Personality; then its body is disconnected immediately and by any available means.
The formula separates the ground from the means. The ground is one: novelty is exhausted. The means — illness, accident, poisoning — is realized as a necessary ground, by the Law of Realization of Grounds. Medicine correctly describes how the body is disconnected, and the system does not dispute this: description and measurement are beyond attack. The dispute concerns only why precisely then, and here the system answers differently from the habitual ontology.
Death — the fact of recognition of further uselessness
Hence the conclusion obtained in the discussion with the Author, and in it the main weight of the chapter: death is the recognition of further uselessness. The word "further" here is load-bearing. What is recognized as useless is the continuation of reading, not what has been lived. The branch that has ceased to be read gave the new before this, otherwise it would not have been read.
And in the reverse direction: if a person is alive, then the Path of his Development continues. This is not a consolation but a direct consequence of the fact that Life holds by Development. But from life and death we learn only about the presence of Development, not about its content. What the novelty of another's experience consists in and what its value is cannot be seen from outside. Looking ahead: in "Development of the Entity" it is said that "people often err in determining perspective, observing the death of other people", whereas the Entity cannot err. Therefore the living drug addict, the living murderer and the scientist who died early are not counterexamples to the thesis, but a reminder that the measure of novelty is not external, yet always genuine.
A comparison with Epicurus is appropriate here. The "Letter to Menoeceus" removes the fear of death by the fact that death does not exist for us: while we are, it is not, and when it has come, we are not. The chapter removes the fear otherwise: the "I" does not end; what ends is the relevance of a branch of experience (of a concrete Personality). But this gives no relief — rather the opposite. In Epicurus death demands nothing of the living. Here it turns out to be a control measure — Does life yield new experience? …and, will there be Development in perspective?
Two transitions: 'sleep' and 'exhaustion of the perspective of Development'
The paragraph about the "next body of Its own of the given Personality" must be read carefully: two different transitions are fused in it, and in the discussion with the Author they were separated.
The first transition is sleep. The "I" leaves the controlled body and acts in another body of the same Personality, in another line of its experience. The ground for this is given in "Five-Dimensionality": the "I" lives "a potentially infinite number of lives of each concrete Personality simultaneously", and the argument is this: in a dream "I recognize myself, but use my experience where I have never been". "Five-Dimensionality" itself introduces this with a warning: "let us allow ourselves to suppose what is unproved". This is a model with a weighty ground, not a derivation, and the chapter stands on it with the same caution: "By all appearances this is so". Hence also the strong phrase of the chapter: for sleep and for death "what differs is the cause of the transfer of control"; the transition itself is the same.
The second transition is exhaustion. The experience of a Personality is no longer new, and Interest goes to another branch, to another Personality. This must not be understood as if the System "assigns" a new Personality to the Real aspect from outside. Already in "Entity" it is said that the Entity is {God + Soul + Development + World + Life}. The Entity is the World, and there is no one to dispose of it from outside. Interest itself goes where experience is new. The Laws do not decide; they guard Development, and therefore reading does not linger where there is nothing new.
Will the Entity return to an abandoned branch? In the discussion with the Author the answer was "hardly", and the precise sense of this word is this: there is a possibility, there is no ground. There is a possibility, because Consciousness, at the need of the Entity, can realize anything. But experience is not stored as a record; it is a function of realization, and a dead end has no ground to be realized again. The Entity goes only along the Path of Development, and nothing on it requires a return to where nothing new is expected. Moreover, "The Process of Studying" says that the System is arranged "so as not to allow any repetitions and identities".
The dead end of a branch is not a dead end of the "I". "Five-Dimensionality" directly rejects the thought that experience leading to death is a "final dead end", and life the "One Chance": "this is absolutely impossible". What ends is the line of experience of a separate Personality, but the "I" Is independently.
Ethics: against escape
The most practical place of the chapter — and the firmest: "one should not think that, having left a killed body, one can obtain a better life". The problem of development belongs not to the body but to the Personality, and a change of body does not solve it. "It is not the living being that decides, but the System": here the "living being" is the person himself who hopes to escape the difficult in this way, while the "System", by the definition in "The Process of Studying", is the Entity, Consciousness, the Laws and their interaction. There is no opposition of the Entity and the System here.
Hence the demand which the chapter does not soften: "to learn to love Oneself and any life, and especially a difficult one". And the refusal of the last loophole: "There is no need to test Fate… for the presence of some bugs — there are none, as there is no 'luck' either". The support for this is given already in "The Contemplated": "everything has a ground, including who we are now (there is no negative experience)". This is a view of one's own Path from within: everything that has happened to me is material of my Development. Such acceptance is not submission, but a refusal to spend life on complaint.
Novelty and its sign from within
Everything in the chapter holds on novelty. This principle was laid down earlier: "The Experience that is extracted is only new {relations, knowledge, objects, feelings…}" (the chapter "The Contemplated"). But if the measure of novelty is not external, how can a person judge his own path? The chapter answers by a hint, the book — later and fully.
In the discussion with the Author it was shown: one and the same action, repeated with pleasure, does not violate the prohibition of repetitions. The deed is repeated, but the experience is new each time, and pleasure is its sign. Looking ahead, "The Entity Development System" calls pleasure the "Investment of the Entity in Development". There too a boundary is drawn: with unnatural pleasures "soon experience runs dry, since same-type events loop". The action continues, but the pleasure fades. This is a small model of what the chapter speaks of on a large scale: a Personality in which Interest fades still acts, but no longer yields the new. So the reader receives a sign that can be checked from within his own life, long before any breaking of the tandem. And he receives it only for himself: the thesis does not permit judging another's life in this way.
Eternal Life and inexhaustible Goals: The second formula of the chapter — "The Meaning of Eternal Life is in Eternal Development" — places Eternal Life not as a goal but as "an instrument and an obligatory Condition". A condition of what? Of a Goal that cannot be exhausted. The chapter demands of such Goals two properties at once: they "must be clear and concrete, but infinite in the process of achievement", that is, strive "for an impossible Perfection".
This removes the strongest objection against immortality. Bernard Williams ("The Makropulos Case", 1973) argued that infinite life would become unbearably boring: the desires that keep us in life sooner or later are exhausted. The chapter's answer: Boredom sets in only if the Goal is exhaustible. A Goal directed to unattainable Perfection does not yield to boredom. A check of the examples refines the demand. "The Development and Perfection of the Legislative System" passes this check: justice has no ceiling; every civilization in the process of Development needs the perfection of the regulator of relations (the Laws). "The speed of data transmission" has a physical limit, but the development of communication technologies as a whole has none.
Looking ahead, "Development of the Entity" sets the "instant transmission of a signal", that is, a task beyond this limit. Hence the line "'Eternity' is not the limit, believe me" is also understandable. Eternity is only a term, while the Path is longer than any term, because its Goal is unattainable in principle. In the discussion with the Author it was said: beyond the limit of Eternity is Divine Providence. Looking ahead, in "About the Worldview" God the Father, the Global aspect of the Entity, is called "Inaccessible. Unthinkable. Incomprehensible". Eternal beings are possible, but the unreachable remains unreachable for them. Therefore eternity is a condition of the Path, but not its limit.
A comparison with Viktor Frankl is appropriate here. He showed that a person holds on to Life when he has a "what for", and that meaning is not invented but discovered. The chapter agrees with this, but transfers meaning from psychology to ontology. In Frankl the will to meaning is a force that helps one survive. Here Development is the ground of Life: Life lasts as long as Development lasts.
The surveys to which the chapter refers show people's attitudes, but do not yet prove that "the length of life depends on the Goals". Direct observations exist. In large cohort studies, people with a pronounced purpose in life have lower mortality (Boyle et al., 2009; Hill and Turiano, 2014; Alimujiang et al., 2019). This is an association, not a proved cause, and part of it is explained by initial health. But it is much closer to the chapter's thesis than a survey of wishes. The intra-systemic ground of the thesis is different and stronger: a Clear inexhaustible Goal is an unfailing perspective, and with a perspective not equal to zero, reading does not cease.
And one fence. The thesis speaks of the ground and does not replace the means. Medicine correctly describes how the body falls ill and is disconnected, and its help is also a ground realized on the Path. A Goal, however clear, does not cancel treatment, and illness is not a verdict on perspective: the thesis does not permit judging it from outside, just as it does not permit judging another's death.
Timeliness and Society
The last paragraph of the chapter seems a practical piece of advice, but it carries one of its strong propositions. "Development is determined by comparison": one can develop only relative to something "reasonably comparable". Hence the demand of Timeliness: useful is what is comparable with the depth of the listener's logic. A lecture on string theory in a kindergarten is useless; a love of arithmetic is not.
From the same principle the chapter derives more than advice. If development is determined by comparison, then to develop in complete solitude is "precisely absurd", because the Entity represents "many-facedness and multi-personality". Hence: "Society Is a Fundamental Property of the World". This is an independent path to multiplicity, separate from the geometrical path of "Five-Dimensionality" ("a human being… cannot be alone"). There multiplicity is required by the structure of dimensionalities. Here it is required by Development itself: development is a relation, and a relation requires another.
The question which the previous commentary left open — whether the Real aspect is a "part" or a "Representation" of the One "I" — was closed in the discussion with the Author. From within, the Real aspect, reading the wave of experience of a concrete Personality, considers itself this Personality. In nothing that can be realized do "part" and "Representation" differ here, and a difference that cannot be realized is not a difference. "Representation", however, remains the more precise word, because "part" suggests a fragment.
Where the chapter ends
The chapter does not pretend to know more than it states: "It would be good to understand better What 'Development' is for the 'Entity'? We dream of finding this out". This is not a weakness of the answer but its honest boundary. Of Development we judge in the measure of our ability to imagine, and no one has another representation. Life and death tell us that Development is, or is no more, but they do not tell us what it consists in.
So the chapter on the meaning of life returns to the Prologue. First of all one must know the Conditions of Being in which one acts, and for this one must investigate them and find a way of investigation. "The Meaning of Being" indicates what precisely in the Conditions of Being is to be understood most deeply: what Development is for the Entity. The chapter ends where research begins, and this is its proper place.
Sources referred to in the commentary: Epicurus, "Letter to Menoeceus"; B. Williams, "The Makropulos Case: Reflections on the Tedium of Immortality" (1973); V. Frankl, "Man's Search for Meaning"; P. A. Boyle et al., Psychosomatic Medicine, 2009; P. L. Hill, N. A. Turiano, Psychological Science, 2014; A. Alimujiang et al., JAMA Network Open, 2019.
(commentary with the participation of AI: Claude)