Contents
  1. Prologue
  2. The Goal
  3. The Contemplated
  4. Entity
  5. Consciousness
  6. Two-Aspect (Dualistic) Entity
  7. The Fourth Dimension and Four-Dimensionality
  8. Society and Humanity
  9. The Fifth Dimension, Five-Dimensionality
  10. Firstoccurrence
  11. Act of the “I”
  12. The Process of Studying the Act of the “I”
  13. The Meaning of Being
  14. Development of the Entity
  15. Collective Realization of Reality
  16. The Entity Development System
  17. Echo (Reflection)
  18. The Real Aspect of the Global “I”
  19. On Worldview
  20. Space-Time
  21. Attitude towards Oneself
  22. Attitude towards One’s Body
  23. Laziness
  24. Fear
  25. Hope (“Waiting for a Miracle”)
  26. Adaptation
  27. Identity of the Personality
  28. Relation: [Reason | Body]
  29. Free Will
  30. “The Hard Problem of Consciousness”
  31. Indistinguishability and Identity (of Objects)
  32. Matter
  33. Gnoseology
  34. Epistemology
  35. Division

MATTER

"Which is primary, spirit or matter?" _

We consider it necessary to define the 'given' relations:

1. [ Consciousness | Matter ];

2. [ Thinking | Being ];

3. [ Spirit | Nature ].

1. This Task is not a consequence of our conclusions; we qualify It as 'Philosophical-Historical', but, as in solving other tasks, we shall approach the solution from the Ultra-Idealistic position (since we have no other). It is widely known (from ancient and classical philosophy) that "Matter" is the smallest part of the material World, that is, the Foundation and the "Smallest Detail" of any extended <material> particle and of every "thing".

Modern science should be considered materialist, and this is a deliberate position of scientists in the absence of data. It would seem not at all important how one names 'the Contemplated' and its Nature – materialist or idealist; but what is important is the Essence of the Interpretation and the Meaning of the comparison in the relation [ Consciousness | Matter ], 'which plays a decisive role in judging about Oneself and One's Own Purpose', i.e. Who am I? What is the meaning of Life? What is my role in the World?

"Consciousness" is in absolute dependence on the Entity; Its existence is relevant only in the presence of a living Being. In this lies a most important Condition – presence implies Reality, precisely the realization of a 'Reason' capable of analysis, of the extraction of experience and of the self-awareness of the concrete "I" to which this 'Reason' belongs. From the reverse position – the 'Entity' can be realized in the Conditions of Reality using Consciousness –> and Reason, for any subsequent conclusion (Determinacy).

In Essence, considering 'One without the Other' must be done with care. [ Entity | Consciousness ] is the fundamental relation at the moment of "Firstoccurrence" (i.e. the Cause of the World), but at the present moment, solving this very task, we consider the "Entity" in 'a Form Fit for contemplation' – that is, in the Conditions of Reality. Matter, in this reasoning, is taken to be a certain Inner Essence of the Mechanism of Contemplation, and precisely: of the 'Ephemeral Process of Illumination' <an Infinitely small detail in the division of 'the Products of Consciousness', i.e. according to "the Law of Realization of Grounds">. Proceeding from 'so complex' a formulation, one can draw a conclusion in which Reason presents "Consciousness" as using "Matter" as material for the realization of "Reality"; however, this conclusion may be the result of analysis, as the experience of an infinite recursive division of 'the Ephemeral Contemplated' into component parts; here what is meant is that "Matter" is something elusive, infinitely striving towards (non-existent) Sources. Moreover, the smallest details (for example, Electrons) of the objects under study will turn out to be practically the same, which on the whole proves the homogeneity of their composition; that is, we do not subdivide electrons into kinds: Electrons of Iodine, Electrons of Oxygen; likewise protons will be the same, but not identical, since identity is inadmissible (see "The Hard Problem of Consciousness", p. 443);

The main Essence of this reasoning lies in this: Matter is no less ephemeral than Space and Objects. If one can recognize This as anything at all, then this, still unknown, will be the next particle discovered by physicists – it will always seem that it is the last, but it, like all the previous ones, will be One of the First; that is, this Path is infinite, and Matter as such does not exist; it is the Unattainable Goal of the division of the contemplated. The Law of Realization of Grounds will always realize the next object of a Brilliant discovery;

Most understand "Consciousness" as 'a Functionality of the Brain'. After everything, we shall say: this is right; but we ask you to focus attention, to concentrate on the fact that another person's brain belongs to the category of 'the Contemplated' (a 'thing'), like any realized object;

If we look in the mirror, we see a head, implying its inner content. Firstly, we do not see It, and secondly, the body is realized in accordance with one's own representation in the conditions of reality; that is, the "I" sees Itself thus in 'the conditions of reality', taking into account the existing experience contained in the concrete wave (read by It);

Investigating the mechanism of Contemplation, we become aware of the immersion inward into Oneself by means of the formation of the "Personal Wave", acquiring experience. At the same time we are always at the centre, representing the "I" (the "Real aspect of the Entity") in our role. Consciousness here is represented as outside, since through the eye we fly inward, in the form of the data of new experience (the data contain everything, including the body and its state), and the brain is taken to be contained inside the head; that is, it is associated with Consciousness in its past <let us say, 'ordinary'>, down-to-earth representation. Although there is this very important subtlety: We do not see our own brain, but neither do we deny that, at the present level of medicine, this extreme is probably achievable.

If this is so (let us suppose it is so), then the representation of "Consciousness" will correspond to how we represent It to ourselves, meaning a processor – a complex 'figuratively consisting' of "Consciousness" and "Reason"; but at the same time we shall not be able to distinguish the One from the Other, understanding, however, that 'the "I" is there – at the centre of "Consciousness"'. This would be an empirical, and precisely sequential, investigation of 'the flow which during life is never interrupted', and outside the life process is impossible;

The position in the relation [ Consciousness | Matter ] is only 'As to something evident' – so this task is interpreted, not being a special Problem. Let us return to the reasoning about the rootedness of stereotypes, their tenacity in the judgement of many generations aware of the importance of having a Worldview (one has always wanted to have It) – some worldview, but certainly a rational one, which, as we suppose, has a logically complete construction; and this is the Main thing for the understanding of the Conditions of Development, since Intelligent Beings, in their general mass, strive for the effectiveness of any actions, are interested in the preservation of their species, and dream of a safe life in an Understandable and Friendly Environment;

***

2. The relation [ Thinking | Being ]. What is Thinking? – the activity of "Reason". Being is existence, but precisely as being alive, in the course of the life process; in the broad sense it is also actions performed on the basis of logical conclusions, not excluding instinctive ones, one way or another regulated by the activity of "Reason". That is, the relation is equivalent to a comparison in which:

A. The products of the activity of "Reason", expressed as Expressions of Will of the "I" (in the person of a 'Concrete Personality'), and forming, as the result of analysis, the Life Process, interpreted and held in awareness as "I" Am, "I" live. We shall not exclude the results of mental activity and the background of thinking (the wandering of various thoughts);

B. The conclusion about 'One's Own Being' and the result of this qualification, which is expressed: "I" Am, "I" live;

Consequently, in this relation we are presented with the conclusion of René Descartes, "I think, therefore I am", and an analogous comparison, where [ Thinking = Being ];

3. Let us consider one more relation, [ Spirit | Nature ] – it is not here that the proposed question arose <as You know>, with the intention of finding out the probable presence of interactions, actions, or at least touches (and what was the Author thinking of?).

Spirit (the Phenomenon of Life) – the manifestation of the "Global aspect of the Entity" in relation to each living Being in the World, that is, 'Endowment with the Property of Life' by means of the reading of the Wave of the Personality by the "Real aspect of the Entity";

Nature – is the Conditions of the habitat of Living Beings, corresponding to those Features of These Beings in relation to which these Conditions have significance;

An extremely curious relation, and it really exists: the Role of the "Real aspect of the Entity" and of "Nature", as we have found by investigating, is the correspondence "the World for the Living"; it necessarily arises at the moment of Firstoccurrence;

The Arising of the Habitats of an infinite number of living beings in their infinite diversity, i.e. –> the Universe, Galaxies, Stars, Planets, features of landscape, media: various, liquid, gaseous, emulsions, etc. One could, of course, complicate the concept of "Nature", but why? – it should be meant precisely as what we ourselves consider it to be. We often call "Nature" the surrounding objects, mentally inclining towards plants, animals, and everything that moves, is dynamic, endowed with life; but we <partly> err in our judgements, because: Intelligent Beings are endowed with the Most Important Role in the World and are the 'Cause' – the Main component of Nature, that is, We Ourselves, and precisely, concretely: You, I, Each.

Consequently: We are not at all consumers, nor parasites, since Everything in Our World arose by 'Our Cause' and exists as 'the Experimental Environment of the Development of the Entity';

Commentary on the chapter "Matter"

The epigraph is the question that Friedrich Engels called the fundamental question of philosophy: which is primary, spirit or matter? By the answer to it Engels divided philosophers into two camps. The Author does not refuse to answer, but first opens the question into three relations: [Consciousness | Matter], [Thinking | Being], [Spirit | Nature]. And here the main thing becomes clear: in Ultra-Idealism matter is not the second member of the pair at all. The primary pair arises in Firstoccurrence: [Entity | Consciousness]. Both its sides are inner, and matter is not a rival of spirit but the limit towards which the division of the contemplated strives. Formally the Author turns out to be in the camp of "spirit is primary", but the question itself is no longer the same. The dispute about primacy presupposed two claimants, and there is no second.

What "matter" is. The Author begins with the understanding of matter as the smallest part, the foundation of every extended thing. This is one of the historical readings – the atomistic, going back to Democritus. Beside it, on equal terms, stand others. For Aristotle matter is the substrate, the potentiality to which form gives determinacy. In Lenin's definition (1909) matter is "objective reality given to us in sensations" and existing independently of them. For the Russian reader the last reading is the most familiar, and Ultra-Idealism answers it directly. The first half of the definition ("given in sensations") describes the contemplated, that is, the inner. The second ("independently of them") points to the external, which, as proved in the early chapters, is not false but empty: the statement "X is outside" differs from "X is not" in nothing, never, and for no one. So Lenin's definition holds exactly by half, and this half speaks for the Author.

Matter as an unattainable goal. The central conclusion of the chapter: matter is no less ephemeral than space and objects. Dividing the contemplated, science each time finds a particle that seems to be the last, but turns out to be "one of the first". The path is infinite, because the Law of Realization of Grounds realizes the next ground when it is sought with interest – "the next object of a Brilliant discovery". This is not a reproach to physics but an explanation of its inexhaustibility, and it agrees with the previous chapter: the content of any thing has no bounds. The smallest details – electrons, protons – turn out to be practically the same, but not identical. In the chapter "Indistinguishability and Identity" this was derived: the Idea is one; the realizations are unrepeatable.

Science and materialism. The Author calls modern science materialist. Here it is worth separating what in this book has already been separated. Science as a method – formalism and measurement – is neutral and great; scientists work within methodological naturalism, that is, they study the contemplated by its own means. Materialism is a habit of the first, deepest layer, a worldview accepted before formulas. Many scientists are not at all materialists in their worldview. The Author's dispute is not with science but with this habit, and the chapter explains why it matters: on the answer to the question [Consciousness | Matter] depends one's judgement about oneself – who am I, what is the meaning of life, what is my role in the World.

Consciousness and the brain. Consciousness, according to the Author, depends absolutely on the Entity and is relevant only in the presence of the living. This is what was fixed in "On Worldview": Consciousness is a possibility; it "contains in operating". Then the Author speaks of the widespread opinion "consciousness is a function of the brain": "this is right". The word here must be read precisely. Firstly, for the Non-cognizant, standing on the habitual position, this is a consistent conclusion, right within its own frame: so must think one who accepts an external world. Secondly, it is right as a correspondence within reality: neuroscience studies correlates, and its work is legitimate. But "consciousness" in this opinion is a homonym of "Consciousness" in the book, and the Author at once shows where the habitual conclusion loses its footing: another person's brain is something contemplated, a thing, like any realized object.

The example with the mirror carries this to the end. Looking in the mirror, we see a head and imply a brain inside, but we do not see it. The body is realized in accordance with the experience contained in the wave being read. If we were shown our own brain (medicine is probably capable of this), we would see one more contemplated thing. The "I" would still be at the centre, and the one who looks and what he looks at would not coincide. The brain-producer, as was said in "The Contemplated", is inside what it produced.

The Author calls this flow "never interrupted during life". We read it thus: during life the reading of the wave is not interrupted – that is, Life itself – while the flow of the contemplated is interrupted in dreamless sleep and under anaesthesia, as is said in the chapter on Qualia.

Thinking and being. The second relation the Author lays out into two sides: the products of the activity of Reason, expressed as expressions of will of the "I", and the conclusion about one's own being – "I am, I live". Hence the reference to Descartes and the formula [Thinking = Being]. In discussion with the Author we clarified its meaning. Descartes did not assert an equality: for him thinking is sufficient to be convinced of being, but being is not reduced to thinking. The equality "to think and to be are one and the same" is Parmenides. By the core of Ultra-Idealism (to exist = to be realized), thinking is one of the forms of realization, and therefore the thinker is. But being is wider than thinking: an infant lives, and a fly, and Spirit, by the Author's own definition, is given to every living being. The sign of equality in the chapter should be read as inclusion: thinking is being, but not all being is thinking.

Spirit and Nature. Here the chapter gives its most exact definitions. Spirit is the manifestation of the Global aspect of the Entity in relation to each living being, the endowment with the property of Life through the reading of the wave of the Personality by the Real aspect. This agrees with the Trinity from the chapter "The Real Aspect of the Global 'I'": the Spirit is the Spark. Nature is the conditions of the environment corresponding to the features of the beings for whom these conditions mean something. There is a connection between them, and it is named: "the World for the Living", a correspondence that necessarily arises in Firstoccurrence. The Universe, galaxies, planets, landscapes, media – all these are habitats of an infinite number of living beings.

"We are not consumers and not parasites". The chapter's result: intelligent beings are not guests of nature but its cause and main component. Everything in our World arose by our cause and exists as the experimental environment of the Development of the Entity. The Author adds: the Cognizant, who understands the arrangement, is the master of His Own World. This is the Author's opinion, and the word must be distinguished here from the title "the Master" by which the book names the Real aspect of the Global "I": what is meant is the master of one's own World, not of the whole System.

So that the conclusion is not read as permission to do anything one likes with nature, it is worth spelling out its consequences, which are already in the book. To be the cause of one's World means to answer for the environment of experience, not to own it as booty. "The World for the Living" is a World for all the living: the wasp on the island from the chapter on Qualia also has its own World. Harm to another, by the ethics of "Society and Humanity", does not destroy the arrangement of Being, but it blocks a whole branch of Development. A master who understands this guards his World as he guards himself, because he has no other place for experience. It is precisely for this reason that he is not a consumer and not a parasite.

Pencil sketch at the end of the chapter