Contents
  1. Prologue
  2. The Goal
  3. The Contemplated
  4. Entity
  5. Consciousness
  6. Two-Aspect (Dualistic) Entity
  7. The Fourth Dimension and Four-Dimensionality
  8. Society and Humanity
  9. The Fifth Dimension, Five-Dimensionality
  10. Firstoccurrence
  11. Act of the “I”
  12. The Process of Studying the Act of the “I”
  13. The Meaning of Being
  14. Development of the Entity
  15. Collective Realization of Reality
  16. The Entity Development System
  17. Echo (Reflection)
  18. The Real Aspect of the Global “I”
  19. On Worldview
  20. Space-Time
  21. Attitude towards Oneself
  22. Attitude towards One’s Body
  23. Laziness
  24. Fear
  25. Hope (“Waiting for a Miracle”)
  26. Adaptation
  27. Identity of the Personality
  28. Relation: [Reason | Body]
  29. Free Will
  30. “The Hard Problem of Consciousness”
  31. Indistinguishability and Identity (of Objects)
  32. Matter
  33. Gnoseology
  34. Epistemology
  35. Division

FREE WILL

position: compatibilism

The Ultra-Idealistic model implies a complete and necessary interconnection of all events (determinism), from Firstoccurrence to this abstractly current moment, in the flow of <Personal conscious activity>.

One becomes aware of this interconnection in the process, that is, in the conditions of reality, by means of sequential investigation and interest, comprehending the content of the 'Static Wave', which is the indestructible Truth and contains All Information;

It should be explained that the Arrangement of the World, Its content, all beings and situations are contained in "the One Wave", from which we, in the conditions of reality, extract only the part available for investigation; moreover, this concerns only our own experience, i.e. what is known to us;

The Wave does not contain the Future – only the Past;

It is impossible to store or to have 1. present (real) or 2. future data: the first cannot exist in principle – the situation dynamically forms the past out of experience; and the second (an absurdity) cannot be data at all;

["A known future"] and ["Development" <that is, "Life">] are absolutely incompatible conditions. Knowledge of the future contradicts Development and the "Principle of Eternity", which has corresponding grounds – for "Eternal Being" an infinite Path of Development is necessary, and an answer to the question:

–What exactly do You need Eternity for?

The World is Eternal; Consequently – the Future does not exist in any form, neither in the wave nor in the conditions of Reality. One can try to predict it, or to Prophesy on the basis of knowledge, but these attempts will not lead to a reliable Guarantee. It is more pleasant to meet with 'the Surprise of not knowing'; otherwise Humanity would not know wonderful discoveries. The Future is only an "expected something", i.e. arising intentionally at the moment of the transformation of the past into the real by means of new experience. The Real, at the moment of contemplation, becomes the Past, that is, experience available. Further the same takes place, by analogy – transformation in connection with the extraction of new experience. The Future is precisely formed, directly in the situation; however, it always turns out to be nothing, empty and insubstantial, and, examining it in detail:

"The Future is like an elusive 'Edge of a New Reality'; on being touched, It turns into the Past".

The Essence of the reasoning about the Future (and its untenability) lies in the necessity of requalifying the concept of Determinism into "Neodeterminism" (neo) – having no future and final phases, by reason of the Eternity of the World and of the Entity, and in connection with the fundamental and theoretical possibility of Eternal life (or 'very, very' long life) given the observance or fulfilment of certain conditions. Besides this, we assert the interdependence of everything – an absolute balance of forces and opposites; but the wave nature does not hinder "Free Will", by reason of "the Arrangement of the World", which necessarily contains "the Law of Harmony" controlling Its safety by means of the strictest observance of balance. That is, we are absolutely free in the choice of deeds and decisions – like God. This cancels all limitations in Development, but by means of Religion and the Holy Scriptures it proposes that we observe the Commandments (…for the preservation of prospect);

"Neodeterminism" (that is, Determinism with the amendments of Ultra-Idealism) in no way conflicts with Development, which is identical with 'Free Will', and is determined in any of the known, significant, as it seems to us, and logical aspects: theological and cosmological, anthropological and social – they are important in different degrees; but this principle is ensured not by Factors of Fate, nor by chance or Luck, but by the necessary "Law of Harmony" (the World is Absolute Order);

Any actions are directed towards Development and the formation of the future – but precisely of a supposed one. We suppose that 'we are able to be provident' and to prepare conditions for the result we expect, but we cannot Guarantee Success and Quality. The reason is in the worldview, that is, in the medium of preparation of such conditions, which are not exact a priori (…and this is evident); that is, they cannot be corresponding or suitable, because they cannot be created in the conditions of an 'ephemeral, unstable reality'. All the components must be exact in the wave, i.e. statically reliable; then the result will always be stable and absolutely exact; however, staticity is not available to us. We are not able to create a Standard, but there are no obstacles either. Besides this, we found earlier that only the Ideas of "things" are exact, while in the conditions of reality "standards" are subject to the action of conditions. Identical objects in the conditions of reality in fact do not and cannot exist (see "On Worldview", p. 335);

From this it follows that, to be able to act more correctly and precisely, we need to overcome something that does not fit into our representations. In other words: "Free Will", in principle, cannot have any limitations, but it has no particular meaning, any more than ambitions do. "The Essence of Free Will" in Its pure form does not imply fears by reason of "Divine Supervision" – General Systemic Control, a Goal from Above, a True Path, or anything of the kind. All This Is, only the Essence is not in this;

Some who lust after "Free Will" would like to govern "the World of People" without having the slightest grounds (every idler thirsting for wealth does not want to learn). They mock the peasant's delight in his freedom 'as long as he (the unreasonable one) ploughs of his own will' – hinting that when he gets tired of ploughing, he will guess that his former Freedom was fictitious and will become unhappy. To them, by the way, belongs the prototype (template) of goals from the life cycle: "I will earn money and spend the rest of my life lying on the sand and resting by the sea". I.e. the peasant will often turn out to be wiser than the pompous dandy, since reason in no way depends on refined clothes;

Fatalism is impossible, because the Guarantees of the Eternity of the World are Absolute and cannot come under threat. This protection is ensured at the 'System level'; it is a Fundamental part and is integrated into the structure of "the One Wave". At times it is hard for us to imagine something, since we are limited and under the influence of very powerful stereotypes, but we are capable of understanding that in "the Infinite routine of Universal events" We Are – We think. We exist – this is the most certain fact of an absolutely reliable and impeccable Model of the World, which <operating right now> we are trying to find out, investigating It in practice, in constant fear – expressing certain doubts, lamenting the probable absence of Free Will in connection with a peculiarity of Determinism;

Conclusion: Neodeterminism (from the moment of Firstoccurrence) and Absolute Free Will. The actions of Beings in the World have no limitations whatever – by reason of Development and of likeness to God. The World is not exposed to danger, since it has a static ground (the nature of the wave) and a Guarantee of protection by means of the observance of balance, i.e. "the Law of Harmony";

It would seem "Solved", but no – now we must think about the Meaning of "Free Will" as such. This is precisely a fictitious paranoia. Suppose God Himself directs Us. Shall we write a complaint against Him to the Police? What exactly do these or those variants of the answer to this empty and useless question change? It is either this, or Freedom. The question is probably offensive to many – to those who desire this with All their Soul, since there is no better Teacher; it is impossible even to imagine one. God is the Only One to whom one can entrust Oneself unreservedly, and in every sense;

Besides all else, we should focus your attention on the fact that daily, throughout our whole life, we take a multitude of Volitional decisions. And we do this with awareness – understanding and accepting responsibility for our actions. Even for this simple reason one can say that we are in the very best conditions. We have the desire and the "intention to know" – some day we shall become more deeply Aware of "the Essence of Freedom" too;

Commentary on the chapter "Free Will"

The subtitle of the chapter is "position: compatibilism". Compatibilism is an answer to the oldest dispute: if everything in the world is bound by necessity, where does freedom come from? The chapter accepts both: complete interconnection of events and complete freedom of will. But it reconciles them not as the classics did, and therefore its position is worth analysing carefully.

Everything is connected. The ultra-idealistic model, the chapter says, implies "a complete and necessary interconnection of all events", from Firstoccurrence to the current moment. One becomes aware of this interconnection in reality, sequentially, through investigation and Interest, comprehending the content of the Static Wave. The wave is "the indestructible Truth" and contains all information: the arrangement of the World, all beings, all situations. We extract from it only a part – the part that concerns our own experience.

There is no future. And here is the main move: "The Wave does not contain the Future – only the Past". Present data cannot be stored: the Situation at once becomes past. Future data still less: that is "an absurdity". So the book has held since "The Fourth Dimension": the future does not arrive; an event settles only into the past. The chapter gives this an exact image: the future is "like an elusive Edge of a New Reality; on being touched, It turns into the Past". The future is always formed directly in the Situation, and it always turns out to be "nothing, empty and insubstantial" until it is touched, and past once it is touched.

Hence the incompatibility: "a known future" and Development, that is, Life, are incompatible. Were the future known, there would be nothing new, and Development is precisely the addition of the new. This is the same ground on which, as was said in "The Process of Studying", the Real aspect of the Global "I" chooses the Path only by analysis of the past. One can predict and prophesy on the basis of knowledge, but this gives no guarantee. And the chapter adds with a smile: it is more pleasant to meet "the surprise of not knowing"; otherwise humanity would not know wonderful discoveries.

Neodeterminism. Hence the need to rename determinism. The chapter calls its position neodeterminism: determinism without "future and final phases", by reason of the Eternity of the World and of the Entity.

Here it is worth seeing how this differs from the classics. Laplace described his famous "demon": an intellect that, knowing the position of all particles in the present, would calculate the whole future. Determinism in this sense means that the future is already determined, only unknown to us. Classical compatibilism – in Hobbes, Hume, in our time Frankfurt – accepts such a future and reconciles freedom with it by redefining freedom: he is free who acts according to his desire, even if the desire itself is determined.

The chapter goes otherwise. Its determinism acts backwards: everything realized has a necessary ground, as the Law of Realization of Grounds requires. Forwards it does not act, because there is no future and nothing to determine. Laplace's demon is impossible here in principle: it has nothing to calculate. Therefore freedom is not reconciled with a predetermined future; it simply does not meet one. This is compatibilism in a special sense – a determinism of grounds, not of the future – and it needs no redefinition of freedom.

Freedom without limitations – consequences by Law. The interdependence of everything and the strict balance of opposites do not hinder freedom, the chapter says, because the safety of the World is held by the Law of Harmony. "We are absolutely free in the choice of deeds and decisions – like God". The actions of beings "have no limitations whatever".

This must be read together with what the book holds everywhere. Freedom is not limited in choice, but the consequences of choice are lawful. One can choose anything; one cannot cancel the Law. So it was in "Society and Humanity": the System does not block choice, but harm closes the branch of Development. The Author said it more briefly and with a smile in the discussion: one can do such things that one will not be glad of oneself, because the Global Laws have almost no brakes. Therefore religion and the Scriptures propose observing the Commandments – not as a limitation of freedom, but "for the preservation of prospect".

With this the chapter's last thought agrees as well: daily we take a multitude of volitional decisions with awareness, understanding and accepting responsibility for our actions. Responsibility here is not attached to freedom from outside; it follows from it. As "The Entity Development System" showed, the choice belongs to the one who made it, and the deed remains his even when it was realized as a way for the System.

The guarantee of success. The chapter also speaks of a limit: we can prepare conditions for the expected result, but we cannot guarantee success and quality. Conditions created in an ephemeral, unstable reality are inexact from the start. Only the Ideas of things are exact, while standards in reality are subject to conditions, and identical objects, as shown in "Adaptation", do not occur.

This does not contradict "Hope", where it was said that a Goal and logical steps "will 100% lead to success". What is guaranteed is the Path: one will arrive at a grounded Goal, for failure, by the Law of Realization of Grounds, only indicates that the ground is wrong, and another is sought. What is not guaranteed is the exact result of one prepared attempt. And the matter is not only the inexactness of conditions. As was said in "Consciousness", the real has no extension: it exists literally for an infinitely short time and at once becomes past. Only what is in the wave can be stable; in reality there is no stable result, by its very ephemeral nature. The guarantee is in the direction, not in a single step.

The peasant and the dandy. The chapter gives a living example. Some, thirsting for "freedom", would like to govern the world of people without having grounds: "every idler thirsting for wealth does not want to learn". They laugh at the peasant who rejoices in his freedom "as long as he ploughs of his own will". Their own goal is "I will earn money and spend the rest of my life lying on the sand". The peasant, the chapter says, will often turn out wiser than the dandy. This is the difference between two freedoms: freedom from work and freedom in work. The first, as the chapter "Laziness" showed, is a goal without Development, and it leads not to freedom but to fading. The second is the choice of one's own path, and in it there is Development.

Fatalism is impossible. Fatalism asserts that the future will happen regardless of our actions. The chapter rejects it: the guarantees of the Eternity of the World are absolute and ensured at the system level. One may add that fatalism is impossible for a simpler reason as well, already named in the chapter: there is no future that "will happen regardless". The chapter also recalls Descartes: in the infinite routine of universal events, "We Are – We think. We exist", and this is the most certain fact. We investigate a model of the World operating right now, and we worry in vain that determinism will take our freedom away.

The question removed. Having solved the task, the chapter takes one more step: it calls the very question of free will "a fictitious paranoia". Suppose God Himself directs us. "Shall we write a complaint against Him to the Police?" What does this or that answer change? There is no better Teacher, and God is the only one to whom one can entrust Oneself unreservedly. The chapter not only answers that freedom exists but also shows that the anxiety around the question is empty.

In discussion with the Author it was put thus: either act yourself, or trust the System, which is the same as trusting God. And in many cases the "automatic mode", when everything as it were happens by itself, is considerably better. This is not a renunciation of will but what the book described in "On Worldview" as awareness: when understanding has become a skill, like a pilot's calculation, one acts without checking every step. This thought has an old neighbour – the Taoist wu wei, the "non-action" of Laozi: not inaction, but action without forcing the course of things. The similarity is direct. The divergence is in the ground: for Laozi it is following the Tao, which cannot be named; here it is trust in the System, whose arrangement the book has derived.

What the chapter is. This is a chapter that resolves one of the main tasks of philosophy. Shown in it: everything is connected necessarily, but only backwards, by grounds, because there is no future either in the wave or in reality; a known future is incompatible with Development; therefore determinism here is a determinism of grounds, not of the future, and freedom needs no redefinition – it simply has nothing to meet ahead; freedom is not limited in choice, while consequences are lawful, and responsibility follows from freedom itself; what is guaranteed is the Path, not a single attempt; fatalism is impossible. And finally, the question of freedom is removed: whether to act oneself or to trust the System – for one who trusts, the difference is not frightening.

Pencil sketch at the end of the chapter